Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Questions related to program, planning, assessing, managing documentation, implementing EYLF, MTOP, NQS and other approved frameworks.
Forum rules
Please read: Forum Rules and Regulations and Where to Post What
teresamc

Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by teresamc » Mon Nov 28, 2011 8:36 pm

Please bear in mind as you read this that I have been in child care since the beginning of October (after 17 years as a primary teacher) so this is a bit new still! I'm also only experienced at what goes on in one centre.
How much "stuff" goes into each portfolio?
I've been told that we must have one learning story per child per month regardless of whether the child attends 1 day or 5. I have really struggled to get one done with the children I am only seeing one day a week because I haven't even built up much of a relationship with them yet. This means I need to do 10 learning stories a week to cover 40 children over the course of a month. I'm doing all the programming and learning stories at present because my assistant is doing portfolios in any spare moment she has. Some of the portfolios had nothing stuck in at all since the start of the year. It was all there stacked up inside the cover but not stuck in as they couldn't get glue sticks.
I was also told that everything on the walls needs to go into the books when it is taken down and that the books have to be "filled up". Is it just me or would anyone else question the "educational" value of this? Surely if something has been on the wall since March the parent has already seen it? And if it is a tracing sheet or something similar do they really need to have it in a portfolio?
I'm just trying to make sense of this. We certainly did portfolios in primary school but everything was in there as evidence that an outcome had been achieved so it was much more focused.
I'm very interested in how people are managing this as I plan for next year.


User avatar
Lorina
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 14285
Joined: Thu Nov 19, 2009 7:36 am

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by Lorina » Thu Dec 01, 2011 1:42 pm

Hi Tess,

I'm so glad you've started this topic because I have alot to say about this topic...LOL... Unfortunately I won't be able to get into anything right now (as I am at work) but I do have some time tomorrow, so I will definitely post up my thoughts and opinions...

Talk to you tomorrow,

Cheers :geek:
L.A

User avatar
fchaudari76
Scholar
Scholar
Posts: 1187
Joined: Wed Apr 27, 2011 8:51 pm

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by fchaudari76 » Thu Dec 01, 2011 9:24 pm

I also have plenty to say about these types of portfolios, I see artwork being done with no purpose other than to "fill" portfolios ... there is no write up about why the artwork was done and what the purpose was etc
At my last centre artwork was put in portfolios but there was a clear purpose to it which was clear to the parents... random scribblings and general art stuff was taken home by the kids on a weekly basis as you just cannot put EVERY piece of work they do in a portfolio...(well in my opinion)
I just found out that my current work place only expects 1 learning story/term (!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!) and again I just see learning stories being made up from some random thing that has just happened ....there is no setting up of activties that the children are interested in and going from there.... everything seems very "staged" to look like a lot is being done, when in actual fact not much is really happening on a daily basis in most rooms.
Anyway personally I think things of educational value should be included in portfolios and general art & craft just taken home on a regular basis....perhaps then we would see more effort and thought being put into things that go into a portfolio.

User avatar
Lorina
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 14285
Joined: Thu Nov 19, 2009 7:36 am

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by Lorina » Fri Dec 02, 2011 6:03 pm

Hey Tess,

Like I mentioned in my previous post, I'm glad you started this topic... I think alot of people are missing the point of what a portfolio is... To me, a portfolio is a child's documentary journey of their learning and experience while at a centre and it can include work samples, learning stories, observations, photos etc... However as far as I am aware most people just use portfolios to stick worthless information and art work in that has no meaning what so ever. Honestly can you blame some people making portfolios meaningless? I feel that portfolios take up so much time, making sure that each child each month has a photo, art, observation and learning story... It's crazy the amount of time it takes just to complete them... So I can kinda understand why some people just want to get it over and done with and just glue in anything to fill them up!

Since the EYLF has been implemented I honestly believed that the experiences we provide to children, which are documented can be included into the children's portfolio without having to do extra work.. Let me try and explain it... You mentioned that you needed to include 1 learning story a month for each child. Why can't you include learning stories that happened during a group experience or a spontaneous experience? Also, since the EYLF has been put into action we are supposed to be writing up "Daily Reflections" which provides details of the the learning that took place during the child's day.. Why can't we add this into a child's portfolio to save on having to write anything extra. If we are already documenting through using the EYLF to the full potential and doing daily reflections, learning stories, observations then I believe that this is sufficient enough to include into the child's portfolios.

Also, you mentioned art work... Honestly speaking (and depending on the age of your group of children) sticking a painting into a book and adding a learning outcome to it doesn't teach the child or prove that a child has learnt anything from it... It just frustrates me the amount of time and effort that us childcare professionals have to put into completing portfolios just for the sake of it.

I do think that we can change portfolios into something else. Why not create a book of Learning Stories group or individual that show the value of learning and the experiences that took place... If done correctly this should document and provide evidence of what the children have learnt during that particular experience. I think this is more meaningful then just doing it for the sake of doing it!

There has to be a much easier way of creating a portfolio without us having to do any of the extra work... Since we are already documenting so much, we should be using this to include into the portfolios...

I would also really like to know how other centres are completing their portfolios and what they are putting into them to fill them up!

I'm trying to work out a better way which makes it easier for us to complete and provides families with an insight of what their children have actually learnt and discovered...

Anyways, just wanted to share my thoughts!

Cheers :geek:,
L.A


teresamc

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by teresamc » Sat Dec 03, 2011 6:31 pm

If I had my way.
Instead of a scrapbook it would be a ring binder with plastic sleeves and this may scare some people but what about trying to cover the five main areas of the ELYF in five different sections. That way if Little Johnny is only coming to day care on Tuesdays he may only have 1-2 things in each section but has the sections covered and if little Susie comes every day (and probably does more art work anyway because she is a girl!) there could be 5-6 things in each section for her. In that way there are an appropriate number of work samples per child and the parents can see that the learning framework is being covered.
Of course many learning stories cover multiple parts of the five part framework but even if a professional decision was made as to what area was "most" suited it would still work. It would also have an accountability component because people could see if they were not collecting work samples for 1-2 areas.
I don't mean to frighten anyone, just thinking aloud.

justathought
Participator
Participator
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Dec 01, 2011 10:34 pm

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by justathought » Sun Dec 04, 2011 2:26 am

While were busy putting together the portfolio who's getting the paint for
johnny cos its run out, who changing bobs nappy, whos putting on the music for steph so she can dance, who is stopping jane from biting anothony and who is reading a storey to charlie, melissa and tina, all this can happen in one minute and Im supposed to be doing paper work.
The parents who do look at their kids books say they dont know how I do it, neither do I.

User avatar
dulciean
Consultant
Consultant
Posts: 215
Joined: Sun Jun 05, 2011 9:31 am

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by dulciean » Sun Dec 04, 2011 4:43 pm

This is a great thread. Thought I would add what we do- My Director ( and the Centre owner) have decided to do away completely with paper/book/folder compiled portfolios. We do all of our obs and learning stories and anecdotes in Microsoft Powerpoint. This includes photos and analysis of artworks and other projects. This is then to be compiled and collated at end of year , to be burnt onto a CD and presented to parents as a digital portfolio. As for original artworks they are kept in folders near lockers for parents to take home progressively over the year. So ...This system seems more efficient and time friendly. Also more eco-friendly?? But it feels really weird as I am used to the folders/scrapbooks also. Any one else using this method? What do you think of it? :think:

teresamc

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by teresamc » Sun Dec 04, 2011 5:43 pm

I would seriously love to do it that way but we've only had a computer for our room (and our room only - not shared with the other six rooms) for the last 2 days! My own children are 11 and 8 and I am dealing with another influx of end of year stuff. I would have loved to get just 2 CDs!
Definitely something to ponder for next year. Think of the money we would save on glue sticks! They've estimated where I am that you use up an entire glue stick on each portfolio. You would have to keep on top of things with taking photos, uploading them and organising them throughout the year and then on a Windows computer you can just drop the folder of photos into a powerpoint album all in one go!

User avatar
Kaz
Contributor
Contributor
Posts: 104
Joined: Sun Dec 04, 2011 5:31 pm

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by Kaz » Sun Dec 04, 2011 5:50 pm

I love the cd idea,However I saw a portfolio once that a lot of important items in it only, event days and child's birthday and what looks like a yearly report card on the child. I thought that was a great idea. Short and simple and can be done over time as you will know when the events happened and also check lists from the year can help you put it all together :)

justathought
Participator
Participator
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Dec 01, 2011 10:34 pm

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by justathought » Sun Dec 04, 2011 9:10 pm

so basically we are still sitting on computers putting portfolio together for the end of the year isnt the most important job interacting with children and being able to tell their parents at the end of the day that their children were nurtured and cared for giving them a detailed description of how their day was. By the time Ive done my 4 or five obs for the day Ive missed the rest of the day and havn't even evaluated the days experiences that have been set out for focus children.
Look the more I try and cut down the paperwork it still feels never ending, if I spend time with the children Im taking paper work home.
And the more and more I try to make things better the more incompatant I feel.
Am I really the only one who feels like this?

teresamc

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by teresamc » Sun Dec 04, 2011 11:27 pm

Sending cyber (((hugs))) Justathought,
I am sure you are not incompetent! I have an advantage in this area because I was documenting everything for years and I'm familiar with working in a range of different frameworks. What I found in my current position (which is my first in child care) was that I had to tweak the system they had in place to make it work for me. I changed the computer format of the learning stories not so any content was changed but so I didn't have to deal with text boxes that went off over the place.
Then I found to keep everything straight in my head I had to have folders for notes to be written up, learning stories that were to be included in the program, learning stories needing to be assessed/evaluated and finally those that are completed and ready to be copied and put into portfolios. This is what has worked for me and it might or might not work for someone else.
The way I have approached it is that when I'm getting stressed because something seems to be taking a long time I take a few deep breaths and ask myself how I can work "smarter" rather than "harder". Another advantage is that because I am new to this, it is expected that I will be tweaking things all the time until I get myself into a workable system.
Keep your chin up and don't under-estimate yourself.

User avatar
fchaudari76
Scholar
Scholar
Posts: 1187
Joined: Wed Apr 27, 2011 8:51 pm

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by fchaudari76 » Mon Dec 05, 2011 8:04 am

In the new centre we are opening in town we are installing programming and portfolio software which means its quicker and easier to input obs and do portfolios so GLs can spend more time doing what they are meant to rather than sitting at a computer all day trying to get paperwork done or having to take it home.

User avatar
catchmeifucan
Coach
Coach
Posts: 358
Joined: Sat Mar 27, 2010 7:17 pm

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by catchmeifucan » Mon Dec 05, 2011 6:05 pm

Portfolios… Well I’m happy to see that I’m not the only one who finds it difficult to complete them while supervising the children. The Portfolios that I have done have been easy and thankfully I’ve completed them for this year… In the Portfolios we have added children individual observations, photos of special events and of course artwork which has all been linked with the EYLF. I do get 2 hours of programming time now each week so during this time I focus on completing them and I can mostly finish what I have to do during the programming time. I’m surprised to read that you all have to do these while supervising children which I think isn’t fair at all… Even though the EYLF is linked throughout the obs, artwork etc in the Portfolios I still don’t think the parents really understand it at all! would love to change the Portfolios to something more meaningful. I will probably discuss it with my director and see what she says. Anyways, it’s good to see that we are kinda all in this together.
"In the new centre we are opening in town we are installing programming and portfolio software which means its quicker and easier to input obs and do portfolios so GLs can spend more time doing what they are meant to rather than sitting at a computer all day trying to get paperwork done or having to take it home."


Dont even get me started about softwares..lol...Lucky for you..Not all centres can afford to spend 1000s of dollars in softwares and computers for their staffs to make their paperwork easier. As much as I would love that idea, I really cant think of my centre being able to provide this when they are already genuinely finding it hard to buy various resources for the centre itself. I just cant believe the massive price tags on these softwares and it looks like they can charge whatever since there are some people who are ready to spend any amount as long as it cuts down on paperwork.

I did see some software previews and for sure it does make managing portfolios, etc a lot easier but the pricetag is insane!! I can buy a genuine Microsoft Windows 7 operating system or all the Microsoft Office package for 1/4 the price than these softwares and that does a lot more functions than these (unfortunately it doesnt help in managing paperworks in childcare..lol..But I am just saying). Above that, there are so many terms in order to purchase some softwares that only businesses and centres can buy them and there are virtually no solution for individual staffs who wish to get something for their personal use to manage these paperworks (as far as I know). Basically my translation to these softwares is "Rip-offs"!

I still totally agree that the amount of paperwork that needs to be done is soooo much that there are so many staffs even considering a change in career due to this problem. But I would rather learn this the "Old school" way cuz I know if I do get spoiled by using these softwares in one centre and later change my job to a centre without a software, then I would all of a sudden find it even more harder to cope with it. So, I dont think software is always a solution since it also has a lot of cons to it. The only pros to it is, it makes it a bit easier to complete and manage these documentations. Nothing more, nothing less..No offence to those who disagree. These are just my thoughts.

By The way I don't want to go off topic here talking about softwares but I just wanted to quickly add my thoughts! If you want to continue this discussion on software then start a new topic.

I'm so happy that I've finished my portfolios for this year... I can finally breathe a sign of relief... Good Luck with all of Yours...:giggle:

User avatar
fchaudari76
Scholar
Scholar
Posts: 1187
Joined: Wed Apr 27, 2011 8:51 pm

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by fchaudari76 » Mon Dec 05, 2011 7:20 pm

I do agree about most centres not being able to afford software to help with programming and portfolios etc and yes for sure centres need to put the money into better resources for the children... we are just lucky as we are a mining town and the mining company is building the brand new centre and are paying top dollar for state of the art resources for the staff & children.
There just has to be a better more steamlined way for GLs to get through the paperwork and make life easier ... paperwork is insane and I just see to many GLs not doing things the way they should which is upsetting.
Anyway

User avatar
Lorina
Moderator
Moderator
Posts: 14285
Joined: Thu Nov 19, 2009 7:36 am

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by Lorina » Mon Dec 05, 2011 8:05 pm

Hi Tess,
Instead of a scrapbook it would be a ring binder with plastic sleeves and this may scare some people but what about trying to cover the five main areas of the ELYF in five different sections.


I really like this idea you have come up with! I think it may be possible to split up work samples, obs, photos etc into different sections. Even if you do a photo observation you could add it into the relevant section. I'm going to see how I can incorporate it into a "portfolio idea" LOl...

Hi Dulciean,

We do all of our obs and learning stories and anecdotes in Microsoft Powerpoint. This includes photos and analysis of artworks and other projects


It's definietly alot more efficient if you do it all on computer. But then again if you only have 1 computer it's a little hard to figure out, even worse if you dont get allocated programming time... I just want to try and figure out something simple where you dont need to worry about all the unnecessary stuff so to speak!

Hi Florry,

However I saw a portfolio once that a lot of important items in it only, event days and child's birthday and what looks like a yearly report card on the child


I also like the idea of just adding event days, birthdays, reports etc, because honestly speaking I think thats what the parents really want to see! It would be good if you can create like a child album which incoporated learning stories, photos etc along with the EYLF Learning Outcomes achieved. For example, if you had a photo of Nikki dressing up you could just insert a card or something which gives a quick idea of what is happening and the learning outcomes. Like a checkbox or something! Sorry I kinda blubba on where I'm getting a lot of ideas :giggle:

About the software, at some point I'm sure that most centres would have looked at getting it, if only it was cheaper...LOL...

I'll let you know if I come up with something :thumbup:

Cheers :geek:,
L.A



User avatar
LindyT
Coach
Coach
Posts: 399
Joined: Thu May 05, 2011 3:00 pm

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by LindyT » Tue Dec 06, 2011 5:24 am

No you certainly are not the only one!

User avatar
dulciean
Consultant
Consultant
Posts: 215
Joined: Sun Jun 05, 2011 9:31 am

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by dulciean » Wed Dec 07, 2011 9:12 pm

hi- just to point out yes unfortunately the digital option is less-than-perfect! we get one hour 'programming' time weekly to compile slides/folders. the rest is jammed in during our lunch breaks/rest times. I have taken the lap-top home several times to get on top of things. Documentation in any form is overwhelming- it seems that like our counterparts in the primary school system, much of our work is unpaid and done in our own time. Seems to be across the board in Education as a profession!it ceratinly feels like we are several professions packed into one- there is so much behind the scene to consider/analyse/reflect on. it definately feels like it takes us away from the most essential part-and the reason we chose our jobs- forming genuine relationships with the children in our care and fostering their unique individuality. :think:

justathought
Participator
Participator
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Dec 01, 2011 10:34 pm

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by justathought » Fri Dec 09, 2011 10:18 pm

why is careing for children involving so much paper work, what happend to good old talking as a means of communication, what is everyone trying to prove?

teresamc

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by teresamc » Sat Dec 10, 2011 1:45 pm

I find it hard that "programming time" is being used for portfolio preparation when surely it would be better used in preparing meaningful learning experiences.

justathought
Participator
Participator
Posts: 37
Joined: Thu Dec 01, 2011 10:34 pm

Re: Portfolios In Childcare - Open Discussion

Post by justathought » Tue Dec 13, 2011 8:20 am

everything would be more meaningful and in the moment if we didnt have to stop what we were doing with the children to write about it or take the work home everyday because we didnt get to do it while at work.

Post Reply